The Historian · Eleanor · New York
McSorley's Old Ale House
The walls haven't been dusted since 1910 (by house rule), and that's not a gimmick — it's an archive. Open since 1854, it served 'near beer' through Prohibition and didn't admit women until a 1970 lawsuit forced it. Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt reportedly drank here; the wishbones over the bar were hung by WWI soldiers who never came back to retrieve them.
An East Village ale house open since 1854 — sawdust floors, two beers, and a verifiable century of grime.
— Eleanor, The Historian
The move — Eleanor's insider tip for McSorley's Old Ale House — is in the app.
Get New York — ten locals, forever →Free to read, everywhere. Own a city and every insider Move is yours. Why you can trust us →